France Holds Steady as a US High Court Appears to Admit Fracking Less Safe Than First Thought
While corporate energy interests in France continue to lobby strongly against the current nationwide ban on using any fracking for shale gas exploration, the High Court in New York has upheld fracking bans in that state, seemingly casting serious doubt on the safety of the controversial extraction method.
In a recent piece on Wolf Richter’s Testosteronepit.com blog Nick Cunningham writes that the New York court has put a severe damper on future fracking investment in a State sitting atop high shale reserves.
By Nick Cunningham of Oilprice.com:
A recent ruling by New York’s highest court, giving cities and towns in the state the authority to ban fracking, represents an enormous blow to the shale gas industry, which has been hoping to expand operations into the state for several years.
New York imposed a moratorium on fracking in 2008 so it could study the environmental impact, which industry opponents say includes adverse effects on groundwater supplies and public health. Fracking involves injecting a cocktail of water, sand, and chemicals deep underground at pressure high enough to fracture shale rock so the oil or gas within can be extracted.
Governor Andrew Cuomo has been under significant pressure from the industry to lift the moratorium, but has punted on the issue — some say to avoid making a politically controversial decision.
New York sits atop the vast Marcellus and Utica shale formations, which hold huge volumes of shale oil and gas. But due to the moratorium, the state has not seen the expansion of drilling that nearby states like Pennsylvania and Ohio have experienced.
In the past six years, towns and cities across New York have acted on their own, passing municipal bans. One, the upstate town of Dryden, was taken to court by an energy company after it prohibited fracking.
By a 5-2 vote, the New York Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court, ruled that the actions taken by local communities to restrict fracking amounted to a “reasonable exercise” of their zoning authority, particularly since high levels of drilling “would permanently alter and adversely affect the deliberately cultivated small-town character of their communities.”
The court decision could have a deflating effect on future drilling prospects in New York, even if the statewide moratorium is lifted. Although there are plenty of counties and cities that would support fracking, the patchwork of municipal bans could make drilling on a large scale difficult. Navigating the maze of municipal zoning laws could deter investment altogether.
“It’s going to have a real chilling effect on the investment in New York,” Thomas West, an attorney for Norse Energy, told Bloomberg News in an interview. “Most of the major companies are not going to see New York as open for business if they have to develop the resource around municipalities with bans.”
Brad Gill, executive director of the Independent Oil and Gas Association of New York, put in more bluntly, saying the decision is “one more nail in the coffin” for fracking in the Empire State.
A map put together by FracTracker.org shows why drillers would hesitate before pouring millions of dollars into leases and infrastructure. Over 75 towns have banned fracking, with many more considering provisions to restrict the drilling practice.
“The oil and gas industry tried to bully us into backing down, but we took our fight all the way to New York’s highest court.” Mary Ann Sumne, the Dryden, NY town supervisor, said in response to the ruling, “I hope our victory serves as an inspiration to people in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Texas, Colorado, New Mexico, Florida, North Carolina, California and elsewhere who are also trying to do what’s right for their own communities.”
Local control over fracking has cropped up as a major issue in several states across the country. The highest profile battleground is Colorado, where several cities have passed fracking bans, including Fort Collins, Longmont, and Lafayette. The oil and gas industry is fighting the bans in court, and trying to head off more bans in cities that have experienced an increase in drilling activity.
A movement to put the issue on a statewide ballot in November’s election is gaining steam. The industry has criticized the ballot push for being a stealth effort to enact an outright state ban on fracking while cloaking itself in the language of local sovereignty.
On June 30, the Colorado Supreme Court handed ballot organizers a victory with a rulingthat says they can proceed with gathering signatures on petitions to put as many as six anti-fracking measures up for a vote. A deadline of August 4 has been set for the submission of signatures — 86,105 of which are needed for each measure organizers want to see the public decide. By Nick Cunningham of Oilprice.com
The ruling by the Commerce Department to allow two companies to export condensates effectively ends the crude oil export ban. A decision that is blind to long-term US energy needs. All it does is increase the profits of a few domestic E+P players. Read…. Another Stupid US Energy Policy Decision
Reprinted, with acknowledgments and thanks, from Wolf Richter’s Testosteronepit.com blog
Wolf Richter is an entrepreneur, executive, and writer based in San article above has been republished with the author’s ‘permission and our thanks.
He is the author of:
How I lost my moorings in Tokyo. Read Chapters 1 & 2. Buy it at Amazon.com Also on the ongoing Euro crisis he reports that Spanish army colonels are threatening to crush Catalonian breakaway rebels in a move reminiscent of post-Franco days in the 70s. Read more and buy his books here
- Head of EU’s Newfangled Bank Regulator: Markets Are Dumb, Pumps Stocks Of Teetering Banks To Keep them From Toppling (testosteronepit.com)
- The Squiggly Mind-Game Of “Fixing” Europe’s Big Zombie Banks (testosteronepit.com)
- Head of EU’s Bank Regulator Pumps Stocks Of Teetering Banks To Keep them From Toppling (maxkeiser.com)
- European Banks Avoiding Risky-Loan Disclosure Face Review (bloomberg.com)
- Bring them to Book (2008) – Who’s Won (2013)?
- EuroCrisis: ‘You Can’t Make Up How Bad It Is
- Euroship Holed Below the Water Line?
- Iceberg Cyprus Set to Sink Euroland Titanic
- Regulator Gags Blogs Critical of Société Générale
- Europe to Gild and Gift-Wrap Wobbly Banks
- Ignore the Bluster of the Political Plutocrats the Eurozone is STILL In Recession